top of page

Not All Covers are Created Equal. Your Guide to Choosing a Winter Pool Cover



Winter pool covers play a crucial role in pool maintenance during the colder months, protecting the pool from the elements and preventing damage. With various options available, each offering unique benefits and considerations, selecting the right winter pool cover is essential.

Let’s take a look at the options.

Waterbag Pool Covers

Waterbag pool covers serve as an effective and budget-friendly solution to safeguard swimming pools during the chilly winter months. These covers offer numerous advantages that have made them a popular choice among pool owners.

Firstly, affordability is a key factor that sets waterbag pool covers apart. They represent the most cost-effective option compared to other winter pool cover alternatives. The financial savings associated with waterbag covers make them an attractive choice for pool owners looking for an economical way to protect their pools during the off-season.



However, it is essential to note that waterbag pool covers are not safety covers. They are designed as tarp-style covers that lay over the pool, requiring a few feet of overlap on all sides. To secure the cover in place, water-filled tubes are used as weights. While this design provides adequate protection against debris, dirt, and other elements, it does not offer the same level of safety as solid safety covers. Waterbag covers also collect water, leaves and other debris during the fall and winter months, requiring regular work to remove them in order to keep the cover from falling in the pool.

One of the major benefits of waterbag pool covers is their low cost. However, this affordability comes with a trade-off in terms of durability. On average, waterbag pool covers have a lifespan of 1 to 4 years. This is primarily due to the materials used in their construction and their susceptibility to wear and tear over time.

Despite their limited lifespan, waterbag pool covers remain a popular choice for many pool owners. The combination of affordability, ease of installation, and adequate protection makes them a viable option for those seeking a cost-effective way to preserve their pools during the winter season.

Solid Safety Pool Covers

Solid safety pool covers are constructed from a durable type of material, typically polyethylene or vinyl. These covers are the most durable option available and relatively easy to install, making them a popular choice for pool owners.

Solid safety covers are an excellent investment for safeguarding your pool during the off-season. They are available in various weight options to suit different needs and preferences. While all our solid covers offer exceptional protection, we strongly recommend upgrading to the Anchor Tuff-Stuff Solid covers. These premium covers are designed with longevity in mind, providing you with a longer lifespan for just a slightly higher investment.

The Anchor Tuff-Stuff Solid covers are crafted from the highest quality materials and feature reinforced seams and sturdy construction. They are engineered to withstand harsh weather conditions, including heavy rain, snow, and wind. The extra weight of these covers ensures that they stay securely in place, even in the face of strong gusts or storms.

In addition to their superior durability, the Anchor Tuff-Stuff Solid covers are highly effective at preventing debris and contaminants from entering your pool. They act as a barrier, keeping leaves, twigs, dirt, and other debris out, making pool maintenance easier in the spring. The covers also help to minimize evaporation, reducing water loss and saving you money on chemicals and energy costs.

By investing in an Anchor Tuff-Stuff Solid cover, you can enjoy peace of mind knowing that your pool is well-protected during the off-season. These covers are built to last and provide exceptional value for your money.

However, solid pool covers also have some drawbacks. One of the main drawbacks is their cost. They are more expensive than other types of pool covers, such as waterbag covers. This is because they are made from more durable materials and require more labor to install. Additionally, solid pool covers can collect water, leaves, and other debris. This can make them heavy and difficult to remove. To prevent this, pool owners should invest in an automatic cover pump to sit on the cover while it is on. This will help to remove water and debris from the cover, preventing it from becoming too heavy or damaged.

Despite their drawbacks, solid safety pool covers are a great option for pool owners who want a durable and long-lasting cover for their pools. They are easy to install and provide excellent protection from the elements. 

Mesh Safety Pool Covers

Mesh pool covers are a great option for pool owners who want a lightweight, breathable, and easy-to-remove cover. They are made from a durable, lightweight material that allows water and debris to pass through, which helps to prevent the buildup of mold and mildew. Mesh pool covers are also anchored to the ground, making them a true safety cover that can help to prevent accidents.

One of the biggest advantages of mesh pool covers is their longevity. Of all winter cover options, mesh safety covers have the longest lifespan, averaging 12-14 years. This is due to their durable construction and the fact that they are not as susceptible to damage from the elements as other types of covers.

However, mesh pool covers are less effective at keeping out dirt and debris compared to solid pool covers. This is because their open weave allows small particles to pass through. If you are concerned about keeping your pool clean, you may want to consider a solid pool cover or an Anchor Defender Mesh cover.

Anchor Defender Mesh covers are a great option for pool owners who want the benefits of a mesh pool cover without sacrificing debris protection. These covers have a much tighter weave than traditional mesh covers, which blocks out more sunlight and prevents dirt and debris from entering the pool. Anchor Defender Mesh covers also come with a 15-year warranty, making them a great investment for any pool owner.

No matter what type of pool cover you choose, it is important to properly install and maintain it to ensure that it lasts for many years to come.


Automatic Pool Covers

Automatic pool covers are the epitome of convenience for pool owners, providing effortless opening and closing operations at the touch of a button. These covers represent the pinnacle of convenience among pool covering solutions.

One of the key benefits of automatic pool covers is their ease of use. With a simple press of a button, the cover can be opened or closed, eliminating the need for manual labor and cumbersome processes. This feature is especially valuable for individuals with limited time or physical abilities, as it allows them to effortlessly maintain their pools without the need for strenuous manual labor.

Automatic covers also offer the highest level of convenience when it comes to pool maintenance. By keeping the pool covered when not in use, they help to prevent debris, dirt, and leaves from entering the water. This significantly reduces the need for frequent cleaning and maintenance tasks, such as vacuuming and skimming, saving pool owners both time and effort.

While automatic pool covers offer unparalleled convenience, they do come with a higher price tag compared to other types of winter pool covers. Additionally, they require more maintenance, as the material typically needs to be replaced every 6-8 years due to constant use and exposure to the elements.

Automatic Pool Covers offers two options for installing these systems to cater to different needs. The APC 365 system is designed for newly constructed pools, while the AutoGuard Top Track is suitable for existing pools. This ensures that pool owners can enjoy the benefits of automatic pool covers regardless of the age or design of their pools.

Overall, automatic pool covers provide the ultimate convenience for pool owners, allowing them to effortlessly open and close their covers and enjoy a clean and well-maintained pool with minimal effort. While they come with a higher initial investment and require regular maintenance, the convenience and time-saving benefits they offer make them a worthwhile investment for many pool owners.

Choosing the right winter pool cover requires careful consideration of several factors, including budget, climate, and personal preferences. For areas experiencing heavy snow and ice, a durable winter pool cover capable of withstanding these elements is essential. In warmer climates, a lightweight and less expensive winter pool cover may be sufficient.

Regardless of the type of winter pool cover selected, proper installation and adherence to the manufacturer's maintenance instructions are crucial. By following these guidelines, pool owners can ensure their winter pool cover's longevity and effectiveness in protecting their pool throughout the cold season. Whether you are looking for a waterbag cover, an Anchor Safety Cover, or an Automatic Pool Cover, Aquavida Pools is your one-stop shop for all your pool cover needs. Our knowledgeable staff is dedicated to helping you find the perfect solution for your pool, ensuring years of enjoyment and relaxation in your backyard oasis.

112 views0 comments
bottom of page